TWILIGHT ECLIPSE? ?

ok i've read the whole twilight saga. i recently read eclipse (yeah after breaking dawn. dont ask) and there was a part when jacob comes to bella's school and tortures edward by remembering bella when one of the werewolves attacked her. i think it was paul. the werewolf has grey fur i think. and he says its edward's fault bella got attacked. at the end sam saved her. when did bella get attacked?

Public Comments

1. um....actually,

   jake remembers the time when sam finds her in the forest outside her house after edward leaves. he was in wolf form then and later he changed back to human while he carried her back to charlie...



2. Bella didnt get attacked. Thats completely wrong. Jacob was remebering the night when Edward left Bella, because he has seen it through Sam's memories. This tortures Edward because he loathes seeing Bella in any kind of pain, big or small.


3. i dont think it was the wolves that attacked her, i thnk he was talking ab bella being attacked by the bad vamps


4. she didnt really get attacked

   but when she first met all the wolves the one wolf was mad that jacob brought her

   and a started to attack her but was stoped



5. nah... Jacob was remembering the stuff in New Moon.... when Edward left her... when she was like dead and a zombie showing almost no emotion and happiness. and he was remembering when Sam found her after Edward left her, in the woods and on the floor... Jacob could see it cause Sam must have had that image in his head when the whole pack were werewolves-including Jacob.


6. Jacob was actually remembering Sam's memory of the night he found Bella alone on the forest, after Edward left her. You can imagine how that would be painful. Bella does ALMOST get attacked though, Paul has a short temper, and he just about transforms right near Bella.


7. No werewolf ever attacked her,but I think Jacob was thinking of the time Edward left her then Sam found her in the forest.There was also a scene in New Moon where Paul gets pissed that Jacob told Bella about them or brought her there,so Paul and Jacob fought.Though there was no direct threat against Bella.


8. actually jacob doenst remember when bella got attacked cause she never did.

   jacob remembered what bella was like after edward left when she was in the woods like stunned. you know when sam found her in new moon? and it was edwards fault she was like that because, well, edward left her in new moon.