Twilight/ Eclipse?

***Small, spoiler if you haven't read Eclipse*** When Bella decided to go see Jacob and Edward disabled her car- Would you have open or shut her bedroom window? Why?

Public Comments

1. um i would not shut her bedroom window cause its her choice


2. if i was bella i would have shut it. i still love edward though, but he was being wwwaaaaaaaayyyyyyy controlling.


3. Open!

   She came so close to losing Edward once. If she kept her window closed maybe something would have happened to their relationship. Edward might have thought that maybe Bella really likes Jacob as more than a friend.

   Bella really loves Edward and didn't want to lose him or have a fault in their relationship.

   Edit:

   Edward just disabled her truck cause he cared about her and didn't want her to get hurt and maybe he was also a little jealous. She understood that he did it because he loved her.

   Isn't that sweet!?!?!



4. I would've done just as Bella did!!... she shut it really hard because I would be mad that my boyfriend doesn't let me go see my best friend, but I wouldn've been able to leave it closed, I mean, after all the love of my life does for me and the love we both shaer, it's just not possible for something so not worth it!


5. When Edward disabled her car, that would have been the end of him for me. That is a sign of a controlling person - one of the signs of a domestic abuser - cutting people off from their friends. That is why I hated that book. Sooner or later that girl is going to have to get a restraining order against Edward. He had no right to do that. Pax-C


6. I would have probably shut it. Bella can be too soft around Edward - she needs to stop being so loving and pliable around him. I mean, she's letting him completely dominate her. I understand it's in her best interests, or so he thinks, but he's using his abilities to his advantage to control her.

   Kudos to him later on in the book, though. He won my favor when he was OK with it after all, but Jacob was still being pig headed and calling him bloodsucker right in front of Bella. Sore loser.



7. i would have so shut my window because edward was being a total A**. but i still love him.

   i think Edward is way better than Jake.( sorry jacob fans)



8. I'd probably...I don't know.

   It's so hard to choose between Jacob and Edward. They both love Bella and want what's best for her.

   I probably would have shut the window for a while, then opened it later, but not right after I slammed it shut (like Bella did in the book.)



9. i would have never wanted to go to jacobs place!!

   & ofcourse i would have opened the window! bc hes my love!! lol



10. I don't know.

    How could I be sure someone wouldn't try to break into my room? Like Victoria or someone like that. But also I wouldn't have someone to protect me.

    When she opened it again and she opened it wide I was SCARED. lol.



11. I would have shut it because I do not want a freaky stalker vamp staring at me while I sleep.

    no, really...it's totally her choice whether to see Jacob or not...he's not dangerous!



12. I would have shut it for sure. I'd be so pissed off if my boyfriend physically kept me from going to see my best friend.

    That'd be grounds for a break-up, I'd say. Bella's way too tolerant.



13. I'm probably going to get thumbs down for this, but I would leave it open. Because heellooooooo its Edward!


14. I would have TOTALLY shut the window

    I always wish she did because Edward had no right to disable her car.

    He doesn't OWN Bella.

    Besides, I personally tend to easily form grudges with people - yes Edward would be included



15. I would have done exactly as Bella did. I would have stormed around a bit & pouted & been upset when he came through the window but I still would have opened the window. I know I would have because if I love the person as much as she loves Edward than it's impossible to not open the window.

    I think it's something that happens naturally when you get upset with someone you love. There is a period of anger & ranting & storming about... but if you really love the person you know that no matter what... you always reopen that window.

    Thank you so much for this question. It was a REALLY good one! =)



16. Shut. Depsite how much I have for him, he would not tell me what to do.


17. open it. love eddie too much :)